Probably one of the most anticipated sequels of 2024, Joker 2 was expected to be a cinematic masterpiece. Following the incredible success of Joker (2019), directed by Todd Phillips and starring Joaquin Phoenix, many fans and critics eagerly awaited its sequel. However, the early reviews suggest a less-than-stellar reception. This time around, Todd Phillips decided to make Joker 2 (Folie à Deux) a musical—an ambitious move that has stirred up mixed reactions. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what critics are saying about Joker 2 and whether its musical gamble has paid off.
When Joker hit theaters in 2019, audiences were stunned. The film became an instant hit, earning Joaquin Phoenix an Oscar for Best Actor, and redefining what comic book movies could achieve. So, naturally, the anticipation for Joker 2, titled Folie à Deux, was enormous. Fans were eager to see where Todd Phillips would take the character next. However, early reviews suggest Joker 2 might not live up to the hype. Critics are divided, and the film’s unique choice to go down the musical route seems to be one of the primary sources of disappointment.
Table of Contents
What is Joker 2‘s Rotten Tomatoes Score?
As of now, Joker 2 holds a 60% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, a significant drop from the original Joker, which debuted at 87%. This difference reflects the mixed responses the film has received from early screenings. While some critics appreciate Todd Phillips’ bold move to turn the sequel into a musical, others feel that this decision backfires, resulting in a disjointed and underwhelming experience.
Mixed Reviews From Critics
Critics’ responses to Joker 2 range from glowing to harsh. For some, the musical gamble adds an intriguing new layer to the Joker’s psyche, while others argue that it detracts from the film’s dark, gritty tone. Early reactions suggest that the film lacks the cohesiveness and emotional resonance of its predecessor, leaving many disappointed.
The Musical Element Controversy
Todd Phillips made a daring choice by transforming Joker 2 into a musical. But why? Many fans and critics alike are left scratching their heads. The Joker is known for his chaotic and psychologically complex nature. Adding musical numbers to the mix was certainly unexpected, and unfortunately, many feel it doesn’t work.
Hannah Strong’s Criticism
Hannah Strong from Little White Lies was vocal about her dissatisfaction with the film’s musical direction. She questioned why Phillips chose to lean into the musical format so heavily, stating that it overshadowed other elements that could have elevated the film. In her review, she remarked, “Why is Phillips so reluctant to embrace that the film is a musical? Why not add a little more colour, some flourish to the production design and create a really messed up fantasia, instead of the grimdark karaoke session Joker: Folie à Deux turns out to be?”
David Ehrlich’s Review
David Ehrlich from IndieWire shared a similar sentiment, describing the musical numbers as lacking in substance. In his review, he wrote, “Folie à Deux simply tap dances in place for the majority of its listless runtime, stringing together a series of underwhelming musical numbers.” According to Ehrlich, these scenes didn’t add much to the narrative, and instead, felt out of place.
Lady Gaga and Joaquin Phoenix’s Chemistry
One of the most anticipated aspects of Joker 2 was the dynamic between Lady Gaga’s Harley Quinn and Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker. Unfortunately, the early reviews indicate that the chemistry between the two stars falls flat.
Tim Grierson’s Take
Tim Grierson from Screendaily critiqued the lack of spark between the two leads, stating, “The chemistry is only lukewarm.” Despite Lady Gaga’s performance as Harley Quinn, it seems that the romantic connection between her and Phoenix’s Joker fails to captivate.
Other Critic Opinions
In addition to these criticisms, other reviews point out that Joker 2 struggles to capture the same raw energy that made the first film so impactful. The musical elements often feel forced, and the emotional depth between the characters is lacking.
How Does Joker 2 Compare to its Predecessor?
While the original Joker was lauded for its gritty portrayal of mental illness and societal decay, Joker 2 appears to stumble in its attempt to replicate that intensity. The film’s plot feels weaker, and its tone is less cohesive, leaving fans wondering if the sequel was necessary at all.
Is the Musical Aspect Necessary?
Some critics argue that the decision to make Joker 2 a musical may have been more of a distraction than a storytelling tool. While musicals can be powerful when done right, the dissonance between the dark world of the Joker and the upbeat musical numbers has left many confused.
Audience Reaction to Musicals in Blockbusters
Historically, musicals have struggled in blockbuster films, especially in genres where audiences expect more action and drama. Joker 2 is not the first film to attempt this, but it is certainly one of the most high-profile risks.
Will Joker 2 Redeem Itself Upon Full Release?
While critics may have their doubts, the real test will come when audiences finally get to see Joker 2 in theaters. Perhaps the general public will be more receptive to Phillips’ vision, and the film might enjoy a better reception once it’s released globally.
Conclusion
Joker 2 (Folie à Deux) has certainly sparked debate. While Todd Phillips deserves credit for taking risks with the musical format, the execution appears to have left many critics underwhelmed. Whether the film will live up to fans’ expectations remains to be seen. Ultimately, we’ll have to wait for its official release on October 4, 2024, to determine whether this musical gamble was worth it.
